Add News Story
Frequent Questions
Advertise with Us
|Feb 4, 2011

Saviour sibling transplant carried out in Britain for first time

Photo via christianconcern.com

A life-saving tissue transplant from a specifically created "saviour sibling" has been carried out entirely in Britain for the first time, reports Christian Concern for our Nation.

Megan Matthews, a nine year old girl suffering from Fanconi Anaemia, was given transplanted bone marrow by her 18-month old brother Max who was used as a "saviour sibling" to save his sister.

Megan’s condition meant that she needed transfusions every few weeks and was unable to fight infections. The girl's mother told BBC News her son Max had "completed" the family and helped his sister become a “bubbly and healthy girl”.

Andy and Katie Matthews, the girl's parents, from King's Lynn, Norfolk, said they carried out a worldwide search for a donor to treat Megan's condition, but without success. After finding there was no existing match for their daughter, they decided to use CARE Fertility Group's Pre-implantation Tissue Typing (PTT) programme.

They then underwent a £6,000 procedure, which included a single round of IVF at CARE Fertility in Nottingham to produce six embryos which were then tested for the disease and a possible match using Pre-implantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD). All tests could be carried out in-house after CARE Fertility and Genesis Genetics opened the UK's first dedicated PGD laboratory.

While “saviour siblings” have been born before with the help of U.S. laboratories, this is the first time that medics have carried out the entire procedure in the UK.

Opponents of the procedure have argued that screening embryos and creating “designer” babies to save a sibling’s life interferes with the natural way of producing children and risks turning children into commodities.

Josephine Quintavalle, Director of Comment on Reproductive Ethics, said about Max:

“He owes his life to his capacity to be of therapeutic use to his sick sister, otherwise he would not have been chosen in the first place.

“This is the big ethical problem.”

In February 2010, a BBC documentary Having a Baby to Save My Child followed two families, one of which had spent nearly £30,000 on IVF in an attempt to create a saviour sibling. The documentary was described as only a “fragment of a much longer, more complicated story”. Writing for The Daily Telegraph, James Walton assessed the documentary as “less impressive as a moral debate – which wouldn’t have mattered so much if it hadn’t claimed to be one”.

“Critics of ‘spare-part babies’ were regularly mentioned, but only ever in passing,” he wrote.

In January 2008, the House of Lords voted in favour of proposals (118 votes to 62) to permit the creation of "saviour siblings". Lady O’Cathain, who put forward an amendment to ban the procedure, said at the time:

“To manufacture a person in this way is to offend against the respect that is due to the integrity of that person, no matter how compelling the goal of trying to cure.”

If you have an account

If you are a new user

Terms

Top Stories

Michelle Hollomon: Our view of God affected our lives

Michelle Hollomon, author of a newly released book titled God Unwrapped: God Is Love...but Not the Kind You Are Used to...
0 0/0 Read More

Breaking News

Quotes
Soon after the wife opened her eyes there was a lot of confusion and motion in the room because all of the sudden... “beep, beep, beep”... the heart beat was back
Dr. Sean Geogre, about resurrection from the dead in story ‟Doctors searched for evidence of divine healing in Australia”
Opinion
The decision of the Tribunal to refuse Catholic Care in Leeds the right to amend its adoption policy is yet another example of the problems that ‘equality’ legislation is causing for those who hold orthodox Christian beliefs
Andrea Minichiello Williams of the Christian Legal Centre in story ‟Catholic Care forced to offer adoption services to gay couples”